Beauty in Brevity: How The Pitt Delivered the Angstiest Love Story in Under an Hour

There’s a quiet brilliance to The Pitt.

The Pitt is appointment television for a reason, so calling it brilliant feels as obvious as saying the sky is blue.

And many people talk about the talented cast, the show’s ability to highlight social issues, medical realism, and authentic diversity.

But there’s something else that stands out about this series: how well it can tell the most emotional, meaningful stories with characters we barely know in an hour or two, or even less.

And The Pitt Season 2 Episode 3 is still an hour I can’t stop thinking about for a few reasons, but one of them being how well it depicted one of the most tragically beautiful romances in just under 60 minutes.

Somehow, with a tight hour to work with, the perfect weighted dialogue, and great performances, long after the credits rolled, I’m still thinking about Michael and Gretchen Williams.

Why? Because their love story reminded me so much of how you can produce something so raw and devastating, even through brevity.

It reminds me of the age-old reference to one telling a story with only six words. Not just any story, but one of the saddest ones ever. For sale: baby shoes, never worn.

Brevity can still knock the wind out of you, and that’s precisely what it was like watching the lost love story between McKay’s patient, Michael Williams, and his ex-wife, Gretchen.

Initially, Michael was a worrisome patient. When we first met him during The Pitt Season 2 Episode 1, he put many of us on alert because he seemed not just angry and agitated but potentially volatile.

A quick, knee-jerk reaction made him seem like a threat to McKay, and it was alarming given her previous experiences.

But as time went on, we learned that little moment was by design. Michael wasn’t an angry or violent man, at least not willingly.

His temper was a result of a mass on the part of his brain that dealt with his emotions, and chances were that once removed, a relatively simple procedure, he would be back to the man he was before it appeared.

It’s easy to understand that in the context of him having a mass and becoming healthy without it. But The Pitt doesn’t just leave it there. They bring in Gretchen, his ex-wife.

And suddenly, we got to not only feel what this mass cost him but also what he could gain from it, too.

Michael wasn’t just this man who needed a procedure, but a loving, gentle man who was still in love with his ex-wife, so much so that he wanted nothing but the best for her, even if it meant he couldn’t be with her.

Michael stopped being a threat, an obstacle, a distraction, or a number. He was a person — a man you could relate to, understand, root for, and invest in — all in under three episodes.

Derek Cecil gives us this riveting performance as Michael transforms from an angry, intimidating, agitated man to someone fragile and vulnerable as he processes his prognosis with McKay.

His loneliness is palpable as you sense he has no one else in his life to be with him during this difficult time.

And then Gretchen appears. In just a single episode, Suits‘ Amanda Schull delivers this mind-blowing performance, as with a few lines and her physicality and looks, entire stories unfold between words and glances.

This love story lives in everything left unsaid — between words, pauses, and longing looks.

Michael lights up as if he’s experiencing the sun for the first time again when she walks into the room. The trepidation in his voice is that of a man with so many feelings he doesn’t want to scare her away.

He brings up that he heard she’s married now, and you instantly know he checks up on her, searches for crumbs of information about her because he still loves her.

And he tells her he hopes her husband treats her right, not just because he knows he loved but lost her because he didn’t, but because he still loves her so much that he genuinely wants what’s best for her.

He thanks her for showing up for him because he knows he likely doesn’t deserve it, but somehow knew she would because that’s just who she is as a person and why he loves her.

Even the nugget of information that, despite their divorce, she’s still his emergency contact tells us a novel’s worth of things about this couple in a single line.

He never let go, doesn’t want to, still loves and trusts her, and he’s romantically stagnant.

It could’ve ended there, but The Pitt doesn’t make this one-sided. No, they go for maximum, heartwrenching, angsty goodness with these two.

Schull’s facial expressions, as we can literally see Gretchen processing McKay’s words about the tumor, are a masterstroke of fine acting.

We see the exact moment Gretchen realizes that the man she loved didn’t become this angry person who drove her away of his own volition, but because of a tumor.

You can see the moment it hits her that maybe, just maybe, if he’d been diagnosed sooner, they’d still be happily together.

We can see the stab of guilt — that perhaps if she had noticed, if she hadn’t jumped the gun, if she had considered…

All the “what-ifs” are so loaded, so heavy, so devastatingly raw but beautiful.

And then The Pitt hits us with the final blow, her last moment with McKay, quietly, thoughtfully telling her not to change the emergency contact information if Michael is okay with that.

We know Michael will be okay with this. It leaves the door open for reconnection, possibility, or something.

It’s a complicated second-chance-at-love story that ends with an ellipsis.

This is The Pitt.

We only get peeks and glimpses into the lives of random patients — paragraphs of their stories, nothing more, nothing less.

But the brilliance of the series is how it makes those snippets count.

You could be literally anywhere, but you’re here.
Thank you. If you feel like helping out, say something below or share this around. It means the world.

TV Fanatic is searching for passionate contributors to share their voices across various article types. Think you have what it takes to be a TV Fanatic? Click here for more information and next steps.