The US judge who stopped a ban on TikTok downloads from kicking in on Monday said that President Donald Trump likely overstepped the law with the attempted move.
TikTok had showed that the actions against it “likely exceed the lawful bounds” of the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) that was cited to support the ban, the judge said in his ruling.
District Judge Carl Nichols issued a temporary injunction at the request of TikTok, which the White House has called a national security threat stemming from its Chinese parent firm’s links to the Beijing government.
The government order sought to ban new downloads of the hugely popular video-sharing app at midnight on Sunday.
“Plaintiffs have demonstrated that they are likely to succeed on their IEEPA claims,” Nichols said in the written ruling.
The act restricts a president from prohibiting personal communications involving nothing of value, according to the judge.
Nichols reasoned that TikTok posts are informational.
“Over 100 million Americans currently use TikTok to share their films, photographs, art, and news,” Nichols noted in the ruling.
The ban would also have done TikTok harm from which it could not recover, according to the judge.
“Barring TikTok from US app stores would, of course, have the immediate and direct effect of halting the influx of new users, likely driving those users to alternative platforms and eroding TikTok’s competitive position,” Nichols wrote.
TikTok lawyers argued in filings that the ban was “arbitrary and capricious.”
“We’re pleased that the court agreed with our legal arguments and issued an injunction,” TikTok said in a statement.
Government lawyers have argued the president has a right to take national security actions, and said the ban was needed because of TikTok’s links to the Chinese government through its parent firm ByteDance.”
University of Richmond law school professor Carl Tobias called the order “a pragmatic splitting of the baby for the short term, to give a little time for them to resolve the disputes and come to a resolution.”
TikTok’s overarching suit challenging the legality of Trump’s executive orders continues through the court.
Outside of the courtroom, TikTok can continue trying to work out a sale or alliance to appease US concerns.
A tentative deal would make Silicon Valley giant Oracle the technology partner for TikTok and a stakeholder in a new entity to be known as TikTok Global.
Such a deal is expected to be dimly viewed by Beijing, where some consider the US move an unjustified appropriation of Chinese technology.
Will Xbox Series S, PS5 Digital Edition fail in India? We discussed this on Orbital, our weekly technology podcast, which you can subscribe to via Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, or RSS, download the episode, or just hit the play button below.