Former Trump advisor Michael Flynn asks appeals court to remove judge and dismiss criminal case


Michael Flynn, former U.S. national security adviser, exits federal court in Washington, D.C., on Monday, June 24, 2019.

Andrew Harrer | Bloomberg | Getty Images

Former national security advisor Michael Flynn on Tuesday asked a federal appeals court to order a lower court to grant the Justice Department’s controversial request to dismiss the criminal case.

Flynn also asked the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia to take the case away from the lower court judge who has so far refused to sign off on that dismissal request.

The appeals court filing came days after Judge Emmet Sullivan appointed a former federal judge to argue against the Justice Department’s request to drop the case against Flynn in U.S. District Court in Washington, D.C. 

Sullivan also has asked the ex-judge, John Gleeson, to analyze whether he should hold Flynn in criminal contempt for perjury for twice pleading guilty to a charge that he now says he is innocent of.

Flynn has admitted, under oath, to lying to FBI agents about his discussions with Russia’s ambassador to the United States in the weeks before President Donald Trump was inaugurated.

The retired Army lieutenant general Flynn, who briefly served as Trump’s first national security advisor, was awaiting sentencing at the time that the Justice Department, in a bombshell move, this month said it wanted Sullivan to toss the case.

Flynn’s lawyer Sidney Powell, in her appeals court filing Tuesday, suggested that  Sullivan has “exceeded [his] authority and egregiously abused [his] discretion by failing to grant the Government’s Motion to Dismiss the Criminal Information and, instead, appointing an amicus [Gleeson] to oppose the motion and to propose contempt and perjury charges against General Flynn.”

Powell also objects to Sullivan’s decision to allow people and groups not involved in the case to file legal briefs objecting to or supporting the case’s dismissal.

Powell wrote that Sullivan, in his recent actions, has disregarded the constitutional rule that “the power to prosecute” rests “solely in the executive branch.”

“The district court has no authority to adopt the role of prosecutor or change the issues in the case by inviting or appointing [Gleeson and other outside parties] to perform the investigation or prosecution that the court deems appropriate,” Powell wrote.

Meanwhile Tuesday,  Sullivan issued an order directing Gleeson to file his legal arguments by June 10, which is also the day that any outside party can file so-called friend-of-the-court arguments on the dismissal request or the possibility of a contempt charge.

Sullivan scheduled oral arguments to be heard for those issues on July 16.

The Justice Department’s request to dismiss the case came after it concluded that it had a duty to drop the charges after finding that the FBI did not have grounds to conduct a counterintelligence investigation of Flynn at the time agents interviewed him, Attorney General William Barr has said.

Timothy Shea, the interim U.S. Attorney for the District of Columbia, in the dismissal request wrote that even if Flynn had lied, the government “does not believe Mr. Flynn’s statements were material” in a legal sense.

The Justice Department also does not believe it would be able to prove Flynn guilty of making false statements beyond a reasonable doubt, Shea wrote.

Former Justice Department employees have condemned the move to drop the case, while Trump and his suppporters have praised the decision.

– Additional reporting by CNBC’s Kevin Breuninger

This is breaking news. Check back for updates.

Products You May Like

Articles You May Like

The Best Gifts for New Moms for Mother’s Day 2024: Jewelry, Gift Cards
Top 10 fastest-growing retail brands in the U.S., according to Yelp
IEA downgrades 2024 oil demand growth forecast as prices heat up
Israel says 300 Iranian drones and missiles downed in overnight attack
Beacon Audiobooks Releases “Beautiful Little Furies” By Author Laurel Osterkamp