New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani has unveiled his strategy to shut down Rikers Island and replace it with four smaller jails across the city.
The city is legally required to close the troubled jail complex by August 2027. Mamdani acknowledges the city won’t meet that deadline, and is now proposing a closure date of 2032, along with a sweeping overhaul of how the city handles people awaiting trial.
The six-year plan requires legislative approval.
The administration closed one Rikers facility earlier this year, but the rest of the complex remains open.
What’s in the plan
“I’m proud to say New York City will close Rikers Island once and for all,” Mamdani said Friday.
The four new borough-based jails are designed to hold about 4,100 people. That’s far fewer than the roughly 6,700 people reported in custody at Rikers in June, so the population will need to be reduced to be spread to the smaller borough jails. Rikers mostly houses people awaiting trial. Mamdani’s plan calls for reducing detention and case delays.
“The first jail will open in Brooklyn in 2029, followed by Bronx and Queens 2031, Manhattan 2032. These jails will look and feel very different than Rikers,” Mamdani said.
“It is about creating a system grounded in dignity. One that recognizes the humanity of everyone who comes into contact with that system,” Department of Correction Commissioner Stanley Richards said.
“In the first six months of 2025, half of the felony cases in our city took over one year to resolve. That’s simply unacceptable,” City Council Speaker Julie Menin said.
Creating an interagency case delay task force to speed up processing, evidence sharing and expanding psychiatric bed capacity would get the inmate population down to 5,500 by 2029, according to the city’s projections. Under Mamdani’s plan, that’s when the first replacement jail will open.
“We’ll work across city agencies to speed up the exchange of evidence and address court backlogs. We do not want any New Yorker to spend a day longer in detention than necessary,” Mamdani said.
Violence and safety concerns have plagued the facility for years.
Mamdani said assaults at Rikers happen at eight times the rate of similar jails, and inmates are held there nearly four times longer than the national average.
His administration is putting millions toward reducing the jail population and improving conditions.
The plan announced Friday includes $50 million for job training, education, mental health counseling and drug treatment. Another $76 million will go toward community programs and supervision to keep more people out of jail while awaiting trial.
“These are the kinds of key methods that we are going to use to ensure that public safety is paramount and that we deliver everything that this plan requires of us,” Mamdani said.
“There aren’t going to be criminals walking the street,” said former New York State Chief Judge Jonathan Lippman, who released a blueprint for closing Rikers in 2017. “From my more parochial perspective, putting on my former hat as the chief judge, is to make sure that trial dates are real, that when judges call cases, they come in and they’re ready to either settle the case or try the case.”
“We are making these investments so that judges and district attorneys have programs that they can divert people to when appropriate. We are ensuring that there is no needless case delay so that people are not languishing pre-trial for years,” Close Rikers czar Dana Kaplan said.
Richards said the effort is personal. He was once incarcerated at Rikers and said both the inmates and staff have been overlooked.
“At Rikers, out of sight, out of mind is the norm for both people in our custody and our staff,” he said.
Richards also said unnecessary pretrial detention can “increase the likelihood of eviction, job loss, and ultimately, rearrest in the future, while case delay harms victims calling for justice.”
Community pushback
Supporters say the city has waited far too long to close Rikers, while critics question whether the city can safely reduce its jail population and build the new facilities in time. Some community leaders are pushing back.
Jan Lee, the founder of a group called Neighbors United Below Canal, said the plan does not address residents’ concerns with construction of new jails.
“It still allows nighttime drilling, still sends heavy trucks through our narrow streets after dark, and still puts the burden of the city’s construction schedule on our elderly neighbors and families living just feet from the site,” Lee said.
“We do have construction until midnight. We’ve had that for years and years,” Brooklyn resident Judy Collison said.
Some residents say the city only intervened recently about their compants, uncovering safety violations.
Mamdani said the plan was developed in coordination with the federal monitor and will be implemented with their partnership.
Lee said she hopes the City Council will take their concerns into consideration.
Elizabeth Glazer was the director of the Mayor’s Office of Criminal Justice under former Mayor Bill de Blasio. She thinks this plan builds on what they did, but she has a concern.
“My concern is there is no failsafe if the administration cannot bring the population down,” Glazer said.
She thinks it needs one more piece.
“To permit the building on Rikers Island while we’re waiting for the jails to be finished,” she said.
The plan has critics, like Staten Island City Councilmember Frank Morano, who says the city should build entirely on Rikers instead.
“We have an entire island the city already owns, geographically separated from residential neighborhoods, where we could build modern correctional facilities. I have never understood how changing the zip code of a jail is supposed to fix the way it’s run,” Morano said.
Lippman said former Mayors de Blasio and Eric Adams are responsible for the need to extend the deadline to close Rikers.
“De Blasio never really got it really rolling. Near the end, he put out a plan. You know, earlier on, he started to follow through. Adams – four years of waste,” Lippman said.
Mamdani cannot change the 2027 deadline on his own. He needs City Council approval to push it back.